Search This Blog

Saturday, April 5, 2008

Between "dismal" and "abysmal"

This week’s “Chronicle of Higher Education” (April 4, p. A15) under the “Money & Management” section ran an article titled “Ohio’s Governor Presses Plan to Overhaul Higher Education” in which President Jacobs is quoted to have said “’What higher education has lacked and continues to fail at is to develop measurements, ... what you can’t measure you can’t fix’.”

Obviously President Jacobs, Provost Haggett, Dean Lee and (sad to say) my own departmental chair are presently in robotic lockstep with Governor Strickland’s business-driven numerical goals and their mis-measures of "success" and "efficiency" in public higher education. It seems that every aspect of the University of Toledo is now being measured except A&S faculty moral -- which on my meter reads somewhere in the red between “dismal” and “abysmal”! Poor faculty morale impacts directly on our students in the classroom (though -- gee whiz -- perhaps not so much in Distance Learning courses).

Although the UT administration has worked very hard over the last decade to shamelessly adopt the “business model” without remorse over collateral damage to more lofty goals and principles, and has meanwhile attempted to drive a thick wedge between A&S faculty and students, the unexpected events of this past two weeks indicates a sudden setback and perhaps a reversal (dare I say “tipping point”) for this administration’s long-term heavy-handed abuse of our faculty and students. The most recent Independent Collegian coverage and editorials suggest that many students are wise to this administration’s word games and subterfuges that have deliberately and deviously attempted to alienate them and their support them from our dedicated faculty. This administration’s drumbeat “student-centeredness” sham was not working fast enough for their timetable of creative destruction, so they had to invent “EXTREME student centeredness” as their desperate stratagem to speed things up! Give me a break!

Our students won’t be easily fooled by these blatherings of administrative blurts and adverts because we have taught them to be critical thinkers. The Administration has seriously underestimated the intelligence and power reserve of A&S students and faculty. When we A&S faculty and our students finally combine our creative forces and turn our full attention as a body of resistance to UT mismanagement and its destructive, dictatorial and abusive practices, we can then attempt to educate and reform these bullies, or throw them out (as we have done before), and to return to our traditional and sacred missions of higher education teaching, learning and service.

3 comments:

HuJia said...

Right, isn't this just another example of a de facto, declaration of a "state of emergency" --here staged as the assertion (backed primarily by the claim that "corporate leaders are concerned" (page 11 of speech) that higher education is "broken," familiar to us
from other neo-con operations? In an interesting twist he goes on to say that we are "victims of our own success." The nature of our success is that we have "mass-produced the middle class" by creating "a lock step curriculum." While his focus seems to be on this bogus notion that we have instituted Taylorims in Higher Ed. (i.e. the Ford Assembly Line) --no concrete evidence is given for this claim btw, it is simply asserted (like the idea that Dell's mass customization is best suited for a public university that is charged with among other things responsibility for cultivating civic responsibility --even though we now Dell has long abandoned the mass customization model!), one wonders to what extent the creation of a strong and independent middle class is precisely a problem for a regime that justifies itself in terms of corporate efficiencies. Put differently, just what kind of middle class could possibly emerge from a generation of students who are trained at "The NewEntity" which, if I am understanding correctly, will be significantly staffed by outsourced dl teachers and peers in the "Educational Incubator"(cf. pp. 29 and 30) (N.B. I am all for creating learning environments in which peers learn from each and other and indeed, in which instructors can learn from students, and students can learn from profs --but is that what is in fact being proposed here in the "Educational Incubator"? I, for one, am guessing no) Surely, this a formula better suited to "produce" docile bodies and minds, and not the next generation of robust citizens capable of joining the other people of the world in solving the true emergencies of the world like mass globalization, increasing human rights violations such as in Burma, Tibet that are instituted not only by the Chinese government's current policies, but also by the willingness of many CEOs of transnational companies to do business with them, and global warming.

Tully said...

Might I suggest re-posting Hujia's comments as regular posts?

Lafcadio said...

The Farmer and the Dell. In The Wall Street Journal (Friday, April 4:B6) the article "Dell's Chief Says Layoffs to Surpass Original 8,800" reveals that Dell "intends to surpass its goal, announced last year of cutting 8,800 employees, or about 10% of its global work force." Now we know where Dr. Jacobs came up with his
"10% reductions" formula. The article continues: "The continued cuts are part of Dell's stated aim to slash $3 billion in annual expenses in three years ... Dell isn't providing financial guidance and offered few specifics ...". Sound familiar? "Asked why Dell's profit margins continue to flag despite the ongoing layoffs, [Dell] said, 'it's the whole raft of personnel practices'." This model of cutting personnel till the business turns around makes President Jacobs' Dell model the kiss of death not only for A&S tenured and tenure-track faculty, but secretaries and groundskeepers as well. The enterprise systems management now being shoved down our throats is plain inhumane. The UT administration is run by "takers" who take everything good till its gone -- and they give nothing back. Guard your cheese!
"The rat takes the cheese
The rat takes the cheese
Hi-ho, the derry-o
The rat takes the cheese."